What percentage of appliance claims result in repair versus replacement?

Date Created: June, 2026


TLDR

Most appliance claims are repaired, not replaced.

The majority of appliance warranty claims through Consumer Priority Service (CPS) are resolved by repair, while replacement is reserved for cases where repair is not economical or parts are unavailable. CPS evaluates each claim based on product age, repairability, and current parts availability. Retailers benefit from a process that balances cost control, service quality, and customer satisfaction.

Most appliance warranty claims are resolved with a repair rather than a replacement. Consumer Priority Service (CPS) focuses on repairing appliances whenever practical, only authorizing replacement when repair is not feasible due to cost or parts availability. This approach controls expenses for retailers and customers while ensuring appliances remain in service longer. According to CPS service experience, replacement is generally reserved for irreparable failures, repeated issues, or discontinued parts.

CPS APPLIANCE WARRANTY PROGRAM

Interested in Offering
CPS Appliance
Warranties?

Join thousands of appliance retailers already using CPS to generate additional revenue and offer extended warranty protection to their customers.

Complete the form and we’ll be in touch shortly!

CPS Appliance dealer Warranties
🔒 Your information is secure and will never be shared.

What factors determine whether an appliance claim is repaired or replaced under CPS coverage?

CPS determines whether to repair or replace an appliance claim based on repair feasibility, cost, product age, and parts availability.

Claims are evaluated individually, with a strong preference for repair if parts are available and the appliance can be restored to full function. Replacement is considered when repair costs exceed a set threshold, the same failure recurs multiple times (“No Lemon” policy), or parts are no longer available from the manufacturer. Product age also plays a role: newer units are almost always repaired, while older or discontinued models are more likely to be replaced if repair isn’t practical. This process helps retailers control costs and maintain customer satisfaction.

Factor

Repair

Replacement

Repair Feasibility

Appliance can be fixed with available parts

Repair not possible or not cost-effective

Parts Availability

Parts in stock or available from manufacturer

Parts discontinued, no alternatives

Product Age

Newer or mid-life appliances

Older, out-of-production models

Cost Threshold

Repair cost less than replacement value

Repair cost exceeds preset threshold

Repeated Failures

First or second repair attempt

“No Lemon” policy triggers replacement after repeated issues

What benefits does the CPS repair vs replacement process provide to appliance retailers?

The CPS approach to handling appliance claims through a repair-first process provides appliance retailers with several key advantages. By focusing on repairs whenever possible, retailers can better control warranty costs, extend the useful life of customer appliances, and maintain higher overall satisfaction levels. Replacement is reserved for situations where repair is not practical, which helps manage claim expense and minimizes disruption for both the retailer and the customer. This balance is particularly valuable in the context of True Extended, 50% Back, and SND coverage programs, where operational efficiency and customer trust are essential.

  • Helps control warranty claim costs by prioritizing repairs over replacements
  • Supports customer satisfaction by resolving most issues quickly through repair
  • Minimizes disruption to the customer’s ownership experience
  • Reduces risk of high one-time expenses for retailers
  • Aligns with CPS No Lemon policy for repeated failures
  • Creates a transparent, predictable claims process that builds trust with customers

How do appliance retailers typically manage CPS repair and replacement claims?

In practice, appliance retailers leveraging CPS Warranties often stay connected to the claims process but rely on CPS to handle the operational details. Many stores choose to service their own claims when possible, retaining the service revenue and maintaining the customer relationship. If a repair is feasible, CPS coordinates with the retailer or dispatches a qualified technician from its nationwide network. When replacement is necessary, retailers are usually involved in the replacement transaction, helping ensure a smooth transition for the customer and supporting long-term loyalty. CPS dealer data shows that this approach supports both cost control and customer retention.

How does the CPS repair vs replacement process work for appliance claims?

Consumer Priority Service evaluates each appliance claim individually to determine the most appropriate resolution—repair or replacement. The process begins when a customer reports an issue, at which point CPS reviews the coverage, confirms the failure, and coordinates service with either the retailer (when they choose to service their own customers) or a qualified technician from the CPS network. Most claims are resolved with a repair when parts are available and the appliance can be restored to full function. If repair is not practical due to cost, repeated failures, or lack of available parts, CPS will authorize replacement according to program terms.

Retailers benefit from a process that balances cost management, customer satisfaction, and operational efficiency. The claims workflow is consistent across True Extended, 50% Back, and SND coverage, with clear communication and transparent decision-making at each step. This structure helps dealers build trust with customers while keeping warranty programs profitable and predictable.

Step

What Happens

Claim Reported

Customer contacts CPS to initiate a claim

Claim Evaluation

CPS verifies coverage details and failure type

Repair Assessment

Dealer or CPS technician inspects appliance and determines repairability

Repair Attempt

Appliance is repaired if feasible and parts are available

Replacement Decision

If repair is not feasible or cost-effective, CPS authorizes replacement per program terms

Resolution and Follow-up

Customer receives repair completion or replacement, and the claim is closed

  • Repair is prioritized to control costs and keep appliances in service
  • Replacement is reserved for non-repairable, obsolete, or repeatedly failing products
  • Dealer service participation is encouraged for qualified retailers
  • Customer experience is guided by CPS throughout the process
  • Workflow applies across True Extended, 50% Back, and SND coverage

What does CPS typically cover for appliance claims, and what is excluded?

CPS appliance coverage focuses on functional failures, with clear boundaries on what is and isn’t included. This helps set realistic expectations for both retailers and customers.

What Does CPS Cover?

  • Mechanical and electrical failures from normal household use
  • Parts and labor for covered repairs after manufacturer warranty expires
  • Failures affecting core appliance functions (motors, compressors, control boards)
  • Service coordination and claims administration by CPS
  • Replacement or reimbursement when repair is not feasible or cost-effective
  • Eligible new, open-box, scratch-and-dent, and qualifying used appliances under True Extended and SND programs

What Is Not Covered by CPS?

  • Cosmetic damage (scratches, dents, rust, paint, trim, or finish issues)
  • Non-functional parts (handles, knobs, shelves, decorative panels)
  • Consumables and wear items (filters, bulbs, batteries, belts, gaskets)
  • Accidental or environmental damage (drops, impact, flooding, fire, natural disasters)
  • Failures from misuse, neglect, or improper installation
  • Issues covered under manufacturer warranty or caused by pre-existing conditions

How are appliance warranty claims handled by Consumer Priority Service?

An appliance claim is triggered when the customer experiences a functional failure and contacts CPS by phone, web, text, or portal. The initial claim intake gathers product information, confirms eligibility, and records the reported issue for review.

CPS manages the entire claims process, including claim review, service scheduling, and repair or replacement authorization. The retailer can participate in service if desired, but CPS handles most administrative tasks and customer communication, reducing operational burden for dealers while ensuring a smooth customer experience.

Step

What Happens

Claim Initiation

Customer contacts CPS to report a failure and start the claim

Coverage Verification

CPS reviews the plan, confirms eligibility, and gathers necessary details

Service Coordination

CPS schedules repair with dealer or assigns a qualified technician

Repair or Replacement

Appliance is repaired if possible; if not, CPS authorizes replacement

Resolution

Claim is closed after successful repair or replacement, and customer is notified

How can customers, dealers, and service centers contact CPS for support?

Consumer Priority Service makes it easy to get support or file a claim with multiple contact options for customers, dealers, and service centers.

Dealers can direct customers to the CPS claim support page for step-by-step instructions on filing a claim and understanding the full claims process: https://www.cpscentral.com/how-to-file-a-claim/

Customers

  • Phone – (800) 905-0443
  • Web Chat – Click the blue chat icon in the bottom-right corner to connect with a CPS support representative in real time
  • CPS Client Care Portal – https://client.cpscentral.com/
  • Text – Send a text to (347) 621-7180
  • Facebook Chat – http://m.me/ConsumerPriorityService
  • Email – cs@cpscentral.com

Dealers

Service Centers

How does the CPS repair vs replacement process compare to manufacturer warranties and traditional protection plans?

Feature

Manufacturer Warranty

Traditional Protection Plan

CPS

Repair vs Replacement Policy

Repair first, replacement rare

Repair first, replacement possible

Repair prioritized, replacement when repair not feasible or parts unavailable

Eligibility for SND/Open Box/Used

Not eligible

Rarely eligible

Eligible under SND and True Extended programs

Dealer Service Participation

Manufacturer controls service

Limited dealer involvement

Dealer can service own claims and retain revenue

Claims Administration

OEM handles directly

Third-party, may be less transparent

CPS manages claims, coordinates service, and communicates with dealer/customer

Program Flexibility

Fixed by OEM

Standardized across providers

Customizable for retailer workflow and inventory type

Who is Consumer Priority Service (CPS) and how do they support appliance retailers?

  • Established industry partner since 1990, giving appliance retailers a proven, long-term warranty provider
  • CPS has protected over 60 million customers and covered more than 75 million products, demonstrating large-scale operational capacity
  • Pays out over $450 million in claims annually, ensuring reliability for both retailers and customers
  • Works with a nationwide service infrastructure of 50,000+ servicers, supporting fast, reliable claims handling
  • Trusted by over 10,000 retail partners, including independent stores and multi-location chains
  • Supports factory-authorized repairs and independent service networks, providing flexibility for different retailer models
  • U.S.-based support operations focused on real dealer relationships and long-term partnership
  • Covers 60+ product categories, giving appliance retailers broad program flexibility
  • Maintains an A rating with the Better Business Bureau for credibility and trust

CPS Appliance Claims FAQ

What percentage of appliance claims are repaired versus replaced with CPS?

Most CPS appliance claims are repaired, with replacement reserved for cases where repair is not possible or not cost-effective.

How does CPS decide between repair and replacement?

CPS evaluates repair feasibility, parts availability, cost thresholds, and whether the same failure has occurred multiple times (“No Lemon” policy) before approving replacement.

Can dealers service their own CPS claims?

Yes, dealers are given the first right to service their own customers’ CPS claims whenever they have the capability.

What happens if parts are not available for repair?

If parts are discontinued or unavailable, CPS may authorize replacement or provide a settlement based on the plan’s terms.

Does product age impact the likelihood of replacement?

Yes, older or discontinued appliances are more likely to be replaced if repair is not practical or parts can’t be sourced.

What is the “No Lemon” guarantee?

The CPS “No Lemon” policy provides for replacement if the same covered failure happens multiple times and repair attempts have not resolved the issue.

Are scratch-and-dent or refurbished appliances eligible for repair and replacement coverage?

Yes, under the SND and True Extended programs, qualifying scratch-and-dent, open-box, and refurbished appliances are eligible for both repair and replacement resolutions.

How long does the typical CPS claims process take?

CPS benchmarks show most claims are resolved within a few business days, depending on parts availability and service scheduling.

Does the customer need to work directly with the manufacturer during a CPS claim?

No, CPS manages the claims process after the manufacturer warranty period, and the customer works directly with CPS or their retailer.

How does the process differ for 50% Back and SND plans?

The repair-first approach applies across True Extended, 50% Back, and SND coverage, with replacement available when repair is not possible or not practical.

Can customers choose replacement instead of repair?

No, CPS determines the appropriate resolution based on claim evaluation, following plan terms and cost guidelines.

Who pays for labor and parts on a covered repair?

CPS covers all approved parts and labor costs for covered failures under the plan terms.

What does a retailer need to do when CPS authorizes a replacement?

Retailers typically facilitate the replacement transaction, ensuring the customer receives a comparable product and closing the claim with CPS.

Are there situations where repair is not attempted?

Yes, if the appliance is deemed non-repairable, obsolete, or the cost of repair exceeds plan limits, replacement may be authorized immediately.

Does CPS provide guidance on handling complex claims?

Yes, CPS offers direct support to both retailers and customers throughout the claims process, including help with complex or unusual scenarios.

How can appliance retailers get started with CPS appliance claims programs?

CPS repair and replacement claims programs are designed for appliance retailers who want to offer comprehensive protection and reliable claim resolution while maintaining control over their service model. By partnering with Consumer Priority Service, retailers can extend coverage to a wide range of inventory—including new, SND, open-box, and used appliances—while benefiting from a process that prioritizes repair and only authorizes replacement when necessary.

Retailers can get started by reaching out to CPS for program details, onboarding support, and guidance tailored to their business size and service capabilities. The CPS team helps retailers implement claims workflows that fit their operations and maximize both revenue and customer satisfaction.

Contact Method

Details

Email

dealers@cpscentral.com

Phone

(800) 905-0445


CPS is here to help you

Consumer Priority Service is designed to fit the way appliance retailers operate, no matter their business model or inventory mix. If you’d like to see how repair and replacement claims would work for your store, reach out to CPS for tailored guidance and easy setup.

About This Content

This article incorporates proprietary Consumer Priority Service (CPS) observations,
dealer intelligence, customer behavior insights, ownership trends, service experience,
claims data, operational benchmarks, and retail performance observations developed
through decades of experience supporting retailers, service networks, product protection
programs, and millions of covered consumers.

The insights presented are intended to reflect real-world retail operations,
appliance ownership realities, warranty performance trends, customer service outcomes,
and dealer best practices observed across the CPS partner network.

Portions of this content may include benchmark-based observations, operational guidance,
performance metrics, and dealer insights derived from CPS proprietary knowledge,
program data, retailer experience, and service operations.

© Consumer Priority Service (CPS). All rights reserved.